Cookies on this website

We use cookies to make our website work properly. We'd also like your consent to use analytics cookies to collect anonymous data such as the number of visitors to the site and most popular pages.

I'm OK with analytics cookies

Don't use analytics cookies

Home / Journal / If anything, rain teaches us that clouds are the soil for transcendence and colours the sanctuary of change

Yasmine Amal for Issue 14 of European Alternatives Journal

The imagination crisis

There is one thing that stayed with me from Angela Merkel’s legislation period: the term alternativlos. She used it repeatedly to frame certain decisions as having no reasonable alternative, particularly during the financial euro crisis, and later in other major policy debates. In other words, she claimed: there is no other way than my way, because circumstances required it. Which is clever, because through that she made the opposition look irrational for demanding different policies. So, in fact, she delivered a diagnosis of today’s democracy: braindead.

Long before the euro crisis, thinkers such as Hannah Arendt and Cornelius Castoriadis were already concerned with the political conditions of imagination and our capacity to create alternatives. The Earth4All research on The System Within points to imagination as foundational for system change, as it is a core component of empathy and helps us model uncertainty, relationships, complexity and paradox. If people cannot imagine a different future, they remain emotionally and politically loyal to the present, even when it is unsustainable. Especially when you come from a system where your imagination is held captive by a four-year legislative system running on conservative values.

Hyper-Individualism has system change in a chokehold

I believe that the roots of this imagination crisis lie within hyper-individualism which I understand as the final output of the colonial ecosystem. Upholding colonialism through its pillars of separation and exploitation, hyper-individualism operates in two directions.

On a vertical level, it separates us from time. It privileges the immediate over the long-term, the needs of the present over the needs of the people that we are leaving this world to. In The Good Ancestor, Roman Krznaric describes how we have cultivated a short-term brain, one that struggles to connect our output-oriented thinking with the future, let alone with generations to come.

Hyper-individualism also separates us horizontally: from one another and from the living world, even healing or inner work became individualized. So, when we turn inward, we often zoom in to a point where we blur the lines until we no longer recognize what connects us to other people, the land and the more-than-human world. Upholding the illusion of being self-made. 

This is a paradox of our time, because inner change is indeed crucial for outer change. According to Earth4All, policy regulation will not bear fruitful soil until system change is accompanied by inner change. Yet hyper-individualism has every transformation process fixated on self-optimization. 

The future is Indigenous

When philosophers ask how to zoom out, make the full picture clear and expand the horizon of possibilities for our future, they often borrow from Indigenous knowledge systems.

Krznaric for example describes the necessity of becoming a good ancestor, arguing that long-term thinking can deepen our relationship with reality and the world. He draws on the principle of seven-generation planning, associated with several Indigenous North American traditions, according to which decisions are considered in relation to the welfare of the seven generations to come, as well as those that came before us.

Andreas Weber offers the concept of Indigenialität as a way of approaching indigeneity without appropriating or exoticising Indigenous peoples, or rendering their struggles invisible. Indigenialität means acting in ways that enhance both one’s own quality of life and that of the whole. Rather than claiming indigeneity as an identity, he uses the term to describe a way of perceiving and relating to reality, while recovering an Indigenous or “wild” dimension within ourselves. 

For Weber, the use of the term indigeneity shows how deeply our thinking has been colonized. We tend to imagine ourselves as observers standing outside the world, acting upon it through the categories we create. Indigenialität challenges this separation by reminding us that we are physically and spiritually part of the reality we perceive.

Reality can be understood as something that is always real, tangible and perceptible, while also being a construct of imagination. Everything has a spirit, everything has a soul, even the world, and every being imagines reality on its own terms. Everything is subject and object at the same time. Indigenialität is hence a constant exchange, unity in pluralism, in reciprocity.

Spirituality is intimacy with the world

What changes when we begin from this premise is our understanding of the self. It becomes a permeable being, continuously shaped by what enters it and by what it gives back. To regain an Indigenous soul is thus to be in relationship with the world, focusing on its interwoven parts. So instead of talking about intersections as if connectedness were a scientific discovery, we shall recognize it as a given reality. Everything is connected, and through this perception, the field of interwoven patterns on which the future can be imagined expands.

The thought behind Indigenialität is not unfamiliar to other spiritual traditions, including Sufism, the mystical path within Islam, which is my spiritual home. I sense spirituality as a process of osmosis: a permeable membrane between self and world, the visible and the invisible.

The question remains: If imagination is foundational to transformation, how do we actually shift perception, to go from a detached to a communal imagination, as Dr. Darcia Narvaez puts it? How do we loosen the categories through which we have learned to see the world? In times of activism and empathy fatigue, how do we reach the Indigenous soul?

Childlike data

In The Kinship Worldview, Prof. Dr. Darcia Narvaez connects our capacity to sense the interconnectedness of life to the functioning of the right brain hemisphere, which develops rapidly during childhood. Playing outdoors among animals and plants fosters receptive attention, ecological intelligence and practical wisdom. Childhood imagination can therefore become a playground for interconnectedness.

As we grow up, however, education tends to privilege the capacities associated with the left hemisphere: linear thinking, categorisation, intellectualism and problem-solving. The more receptive modes of attention associated with the right hemisphere — imagination and relational attunement — can become less dominant. Yet they do not disappear. We reach them when we loosen our grip on analytical and problem-solving modes of thinking. Narvaez describes this state through the concept of flow: a liminal space in which perception becomes wider and more receptive to relationships between things. 

Such a flow-like, trance-like state can be accessed in different, natural, ways: through movement, prayer, meditation. The childlike way of perceiving and interacting with the world, and this receptive state of flow, can both reconnect us to our Indigenous soul.

I reached both through art.

Transcendence is just another soil

Working as a policy advisor to the German government, I realized how deep our imagination crisis is. There was little space for uncertainty, difference or, God forbid, intuition. I experienced this particularly strongly as a woman of colour. I was burning out from a junior job with senior responsibilities yet little potential for growth. So, I started to give my artistic career a serious try. Little did I know back then that creative self-therapy would become a meadow in the forest that was my life, where I found the origins of my soul.

Without diving too deeply into the reality of being a spiritual woman in the Western world, before art, I would not have dared to share that the more I paint, the brighter the light I receive becomes. The more I paint, the more my soul remembers that it is connected to a divine existence. It is here that I accessed this state of flow, where I truly experienced transcendence. Like an out-of-body experience, in which I am no longer sure whether I am the one who paints.

The meadow became a sanctuary I build with colours, and within these colours, I met Him. The more I paint, the larger the meadow becomes, the stronger the sanctuary, as if I am dancing with the brush and the trees bend back to make room for Him, for His light. In Sufi tradition, the soul comes to earth, forgetting its origins, and through dhikr, divine remembrance, reaches toward its original state, the fitrah. And through art I remembered. 

What might appear as an extreme career change was somehow more like switching lanes: two parallel paths heading in the same direction, the same intention. Yet I found that art has a unique potential for transformation precisely because, at its essence, it can become a spiritual practice. It transcends reality and blurs existing lines. Art can access a place within the soul that is not oversaturated by politics, information and empathy. For the purpose of this text, I will call this place the original data.

Abstract art, in particular, can create such a reset by disrupting the familiar patterns through which our brains recognize and analytically process the world. For Wassily Kandinsky — often described in Western art history as the father of abstraction, a term I resist given the Eurocentric biases through which art history itself has been constructed — the transformative potential of art lies precisely in its ability to confuse and unsettle.

Abstraction opens a door to unlearning and reconfiguring perception, a place for remembering. It brings us closer to a childlike naivety, to a mode of perception before analytical categories took over. It is something that I love to witness when observers stand before my paintings: when the eye wanders and the mind has not yet caught up. That little gap is where confusion and imagination begin, and you can see the same wide eyes, slightly confused smile, that you see on a child’s face when they encounter something for the first time. Within this moment, transformation makes its baby steps.

Abstract art gives us time to remain with something before we understand it, both as observer and artist. Combined with colours, this becomes even more potent. Theosophical artists such as Hilma af Klint and Wassily Kandinsky actively explored this “power which directly influences the soul” and shared a belief in the metaphysical dimension of abstraction. Every soul reacts to a colour differently as the encounter is a symbiosis of many factors. I understand colours as the eternal languages of the universe, a symbol for interconnectedness, for they emerge from the encounter between matter, light, observer and environment. Blue, for example, can be the result of a symbiosis of multiple factors, creating the illusion of a radiant blue where there is no blue pigment at all. The butterfly may have brown wings, while the structure of its surface and the way it interacts with light create the blue that we see. When this changes, the blue disappears.

Colour speak to the senses, creates harmony or, at least, a dialogue within, and extend beyond the visual capacity of a being. I believe colours remind souls of their eternal structures, ignite a sense of awe, evoke a feeling of transcendence – experiences associated with shifts in self-perception, connectedness and behaviour.

This interplay between soul, abstraction and colour is perhaps exactly what an imagination crisis requires; a disruption of the perceptual framework, a moment of transcendent connection. A reset through confusion, and then a meadow. 

Here, I learned through Indigenous knowledge systems that everything is connected and through Islam that the self can be transformed when we find the essence of the soul. Within my meadow, I realized that my artistic process was less about expressing myself than becoming receptive, surrendering to the play of observation. And when it rains within this meadow, I learn that the clouds are confusion, and another soil at the same time. For beyond them is the sky and when light comes through, a rainbow emerges. And maybe colours do not show us where to go, as the metaphor would suggest. Instead, they midwife the soul back to its fitrah, its original data, re-indigenizing it. If anything, rain teaches us that clouds are the soil for transcendence, and colours the sanctuary of change. 

Yasmine Amal explores the intersections of collective transformation, spirituality, and decolonial thought through an Indigenous and Sufi lens. She is a self-taught artist, political scientist, and mediator. Before dedicating herself to art, she worked for GIZ with a focus on religion and social cohesion. Drawing from her Amazigh heritage, her practice reflects on forms of existence beyond human-centered perspectives. Through abstract landscapes, she considers the relationship between ego and soul, as well as the intimate connection between humans and the living world, while touching upon Theosophical thought.