Cookies on this website

We use cookies to make our website work properly. We'd also like your consent to use analytics cookies to collect anonymous data such as the number of visitors to the site and most popular pages.

I'm OK with analytics cookies

Don't use analytics cookies

Home / Journal / Grounding the Cloud: Structural Racism, Environmental Injustice, and Invisible Infrastructures in European Roma Settlements

Anna Orsós for Issue 14 of the European Alternatives Journal

Introduction

In contemporary European political and technological debates, “the cloud” is regularly romanticised as an immaterial, borderless space of connectivity, data sovereignty, and ecological transition. Yet, as the call for TRANSEUROPA Festival 2026 highlights, clouds are never weightless or neutral. They depend on physical energy systems, natural resources, concrete infrastructure, and political choices that dictate who is integrated and who remains systematically excluded.

While European institutions discuss artificial intelligence, digital sovereignty, and transparent data networks (“Digital & Atmospheric Commons”), this rhetoric breaks down entirely when viewed from the informal Roma segregated settlements across Eastern and Central Europe. For these communities, the “cloud” is experienced not as an instrument of progress, but as a dual crisis of institutional neglect: a harmful material atmosphere of toxic smoke, water scarcity, and climate stress, existing alongside the total absence of the digital infrastructure required to participate in modern society.

This dynamic is not an accidental failure of development. It is the product of centuries of institutional racism and structural rejection of minority identity. The system operates as an unbroken spiral: educational segregation limits future options, forcing adults into underpaid, dangerous physical labour. These low wages prevent families from securing safe housing or healthy living conditions, locking generation after generation into physical and social isolation. By examining the lived realities of segregated Roma settlements, this article demonstrates that any meaningful effort to “reclaim the cloud” must begin by dismantling the material structures of racialized discrimination.

The Atmospheric Cloud: Environmental Injustice and the criminalisation of Survival

While European green policies focus on corporate decarbonisation and smart resource management, residents in segregated settlements are denied access to the most basic atmospheric commons: clean air, safe housing, and drinking water. Located in former industrial valleys or isolated areas cut off from municipal grids, these communities bear the brunt of environmental neglect.

Field research conducted in early 2026 demonstrates how climate instability severely impacts substandard housing. Without insulation, homes become extreme heat traps during summer heatwaves, with indoor temperatures reaching dangerous levels. In winter, erratic weather and sudden, heavy rainstorms cause surface runoff on unpaved roads, flooding self-built homes, eroding their foundations, and washing contaminated water through communal spaces.

Access to basic ecological resources is systematically restricted. In many settlements, a majority of households lack indoor plumbing or running water. When public standpipes freeze in winter or dry up during summer droughts, women and children must walk several kilometres multiple times a day to collect water, using carts or strollers, with each round trip taking at least half an hour on foot. When residents petition local authorities to extend water lines, they face prohibitive, unaffordable connection fees, effectively trapping them without clean water for decades.

Energy poverty further illustrates this systemic abandonment. Without access to social heating schemes or municipal gas lines, families rely entirely on firewood. During extreme cold snaps, when financial means are exhausted, residents burn old furniture or collect wood from nearby forests. Under current regulations, gathering fallen wood for immediate household heating is prosecuted as theft, leading to fines and imprisonment for household heads. The burning of substandard materials creates a localized, toxic atmosphere – a suffocating smoke that causes chronic respiratory and kidney illnesses among children. Survival strategies forced upon the community by structural neglect are thus met with policing and imprisonment rather than infrastructural investment.

The Invisible Digital Infrastructure: Exclusion by Design

If the atmospheric cloud brings environmental harm, the digital cloud is defined by its stark absence. State administration, educational portals, and public services increasingly move online, assuming every citizen possesses broadband access and personal devices. In segregated settlements, these prerequisite conditions do not exist.

Without electricity grids, internet connections, or computers, Roma children are structurally blocked from acquiring digital literacy. Rather than serving as a bridge to inclusion, the “Smart City” and “Digital Europe” framework creates new barriers. During remote learning or when digital assignments are required, children living without electricity or hardware are penalised for non-compliance.

This reliance on digital administrative systems also enforces mobility barriers. Public transport connecting isolated settlements to urban centers is infrequent and disproportionately expensive for families with multiple children. During the school year, overcrowded buses frequently leave children stranded, causing them to arrive late at school. Because there are no paved footpaths, children must walk through mud and ditches, often arriving at school soaked and dirty without spare clothing. Instead of offering support, educational institutions routinely demand immediate digital or photographic proof from parents to excuse delays. Failure to navigate these tech-centric bureaucratic demands triggers formal child protection interventions. Technology is thus used as an instrument of surveillance and administrative control against poor families rather than a tool for empowerment.

Gendered Inequality and Health Barriers in the Analogue Shadow

The combination of infrastructural neglect and institutional discrimination creates severe hardships for Roma women, who manage domestic labour, childcare, and family health under extreme conditions.

Field workshops conducted in 2026 on health rights and reproductive care highlighted how the lack of local services damages women’s health. Basic medical care is often unavailable locally, as general practitioners routinely refuse to practice in segregated settlements even when facilities are constructed. To access gynecological or prenatal care, women must travel long distances on public transit and face waiting lists of up to four months for an appointment. In hospital settings, women report degrading treatment, denial of pain relief, and physical segregation during childbirth.

Period poverty clearly illustrates the physical reality of these barriers. Basic menstrual products are treated as luxury items due to extreme poverty. To buy hygiene supplies, women must travel long distances to urban centers, spending a significant portion of their daily household budget on transit fees alone –an amount comparable to the price of the products themselves. When public restrooms charge entry fees, women are forced to rely on makeshift alternatives until they return home. In a society where health management and rights information are increasingly platformised, women living without digital access or financial resources are cut off from essential support networks.

Conclusion: Demanding Grounded Infrastructure and Institutional Justice

The call to reclaim the cloud as a commons must be evaluated against the lived reality of institutional racism. A democratic digital or ecological transition cannot take place while millions of minority citizens across Europe are denied clean air, basic utilities, and equal protection under the law.

To move beyond the rhetoric of digital progress, European policy frameworks must address three core priorities:

Environmental and Housing Justice: Treating clean drinking water, electricity, safe housing, and paved roads as non-negotiable human rights. Environmental adaptation funds must directly finance housing insulation, water connections, and clean local energy in segregated settlements rather than focusing on consumer-level responsibility.

Universal Digital Infrastructure: Recognizing internet access, hardware, and digital tools as essential public utilities rather than private commodities. Digital sovereignty must ensure equal educational resources for every child, ending the practice of penalizing marginalized families for structural deficits.

Ending Institutional Racism and Criminalisation: Dismantling segregated schooling systems and ending the prosecution of poverty. State policies must focus on providing fair wages, real employment opportunities, and respectful public services, rather than punishing survival strategies.

Until public infrastructure, clean water, transport networks, and non-discriminatory institutions reach the segregated settlements of Europe, “the cloud” will remain a mechanism of division and extraction. Reclaiming the cloud requires confronting institutional racism at its roots, ensuring that both physical and digital infrastructures serve all communities equally.

Anna/ Anikó Orsós is a human rights expert, ERRC Women’s Rights Officer, and Harvard FXB Fellow in the 3-year Fostering Strength: Romani Feminist Leadership for Climate Action initiative, focusing on climate justice and its impacts on Romani women. With over two decades of experience, she addresses racial, gender, and environmental discrimination across Europe, having authored landmark studies for the ERGO Network and served as an expert advisor to the European Economic and Social Committee (EESC). As the director of the Amrita OBK Association since 2003 and founder of the Roma Women’s Informal Network, she bridges grassroots advocacy in with international policy empowering Romani women and youth through access to quality education, labor market inclusion, civic engagement, and Romani cultural pride.